Flagstone vs. Pavers: What’s the Difference?

Many options fall under the hardscaping category, from sidewalks, walkways, and patios to retaining walls. Choosing which type of hardscaping project you want is the first step; the second step is selecting the right materials. Whether you choose from durable concrete pavers, elegant natural stone like flagstone, or a budget-friendly option like gravel, hardscaping transforms outdoor spaces into lasting, visually appealing environments.

However, when choosing between flagstone and pavers (two of the most popular choices), it’s important to consider the different aesthetics and functional purposes before making a decision. This blog will help you understand the differences, benefits, and versatility of both materials so you can make an educated decision.

What is Flagstone?

Flagstone is a flat, sedimentary rock commonly used for paving walkways, patios, and garden paths. It is typically made from sandstone, limestone, or slate and is valued for its natural, irregular shapes, which create a rustic and organic aesthetic. The stone splits into thin layers, making it easy to arrange in unique patterns. Flagstone is known for its durability, slip resistance, and ability to withstand various weather conditions, making it a popular choice for residential and commercial landscaping projects. It can be installed with mortar for a solid surface and laid in sand or gravel for a more natural look. Flagstone can also be cut to size if you want a more contemporary or uniform look with the surface texture or color of a natural product.

One of the flagstone's greatest benefits is its value—it offers a timeless look at an affordable cost per square foot. Additionally, installation is relatively simple and can often be completed in just one day. Whether your project calls for subtle earth tones or bold pops of color, flagstone’s versatility makes it a smart choice for achieving your desired aesthetic. So, if you want to elevate your outdoor space’s look without breaking the bank, consider incorporating flagstone into your design plan.

What are Pavers? 

Pavers are concrete or brick, designed to create durable surfaces such as driveways, patios, and walkways. They come in various shapes, sizes, and colors, allowing for customizable patterns and designs. Unlike poured concrete, pavers are installed piece by piece over a compacted base, making them more resistant to cracking due to ground movement. Their interlocking design provides strength and flexibility and can be easily replaced if damaged. Pavers are popular for outdoor spaces because of their aesthetic appeal, longevity, and low maintenance requirements.

Key Differences Between Flagstone and Pavers

The four main differences between flagstone and pavers include material origin, appearance, installation, and durability. Neither is better or worse; it depends on the project you’re planning and which material would be better. 

Material Origin

Pavers are considered manufactured, meaning they’re artificially produced using materials like concrete, brick, or composite stone. They’re made in controlled environments, ensuring uniform size, shape, and color. Manufacturing allows added strength, custom textures, and color variations to match design preferences. 

Conversely, flagstone is a naturally occurring sedimentary rock quarried and chopped or cut into slabs. Since it forms naturally over time, each piece is unique in shape, texture, and color, giving it an organic and rustic appearance. Unlike manufactured pavers, flagstone has irregular edges and varying thicknesses, making installation more labor-intensive and creating a more natural aesthetic.

Appearance

Because pavers are manufactured, they have a more uniform, structured, and consistent appearance. If you’re looking for an ordered, well-organized walkway, patio, etc., pavers are the way to go.

Flagstone is more organic with irregular shapes or custom-cut for modern looks. This gives a different, more natural aesthetic.

Installation

Due to their uniformity, pavers are generally easier to install. They can be interlocked for stability and create a pattern that is easy to follow from the beginning to the end. 

Flagstone requires more skill because of its irregular shapes. These can be laid with gaps for a more natural look and less uniform.

Durability

Pavers are known for their durability and resistance to cracking. Due to their uniformity and installation patterns, they’re easier to replace as individual units if they crack.  

Flagstone is highly durable. However, depending on your chosen style and color, it may require sealing to prevent staining. 

The Benefits of Flagstone (Natural Material)

Flagstone is a popular material for outdoor spaces due to its natural beauty, durability, and sustainability. Each piece is unique, featuring organic color variations and textures that add character to patios, walkways, and garden paths. Its versatility complements rustic and contemporary designs, making it a flexible choice for different aesthetics. 

Beyond its visual appeal, flagstone is incredibly durable and can withstand heavy foot traffic and outdoor elements for years. Since it’s a naturally occurring stone, it is an eco-friendly option that requires minimal processing, reducing environmental impact. Also, flagstone remains cooler under the sun than many manufactured materials, providing a comfortable surface even in hot climates.

The Benefits of Pavers (Manufactured Material)

Pavers are also popular for outdoor surfaces due to their versatility, ease of installation, and cost-effectiveness. Available in a wide range of colors, patterns, and textures, they can be customized to match any design style, from traditional to modern. Their uniform shape and size make installation more efficient and straightforward than natural stone, reducing labor time and costs. 

Pavers are also low-maintenance, as they resist stains and can be easily cleaned with basic upkeep. Individual pavers can be replaced without disrupting the entire surface if damage occurs. Additionally, they are often more budget-friendly than natural stone, making them an attractive option for homeowners seeking aesthetic appeal and affordability. 

Choosing the Right Material for Your Project

Although flagstone and pavers are excellent options for outdoor spaces, the best choice depends on your project's specific needs. Flagstone is ideal for a natural, organic look, with unique textures and color variations that blend seamlessly into the surrounding landscape. Its irregular shapes allow for creative, freeform designs, perfect for rustic and contemporary aesthetics. 

On the other hand, if you prefer a more structured uniform appearance with a quicker installation process, pavers are the better option. Their consistent shape and size make them easier to install, while their durability and low-maintenance qualities ensure long-lasting beauty with minimal upkeep. Also, pavers offer various design possibilities with multiple colors, patterns, and finishes, allowing complete customization to suit your style. 

Ultimately, both materials provide durability and aesthetic appeal–it all depends on your design vision and practical requirements. 

Why Choose Minick Materials?

For over 60 years, Minick Materials has been helping contractors, builders, architects, and homeowners bring their visions to life. We provide various flagstones and pavers, building stones, soils and sands, decorative rocks, boulders, and more. 

Some flagstone options from Minick Materials include Blue Baron, Moss Wall, Rainbow, Rose Flagstone, and more.

Our pavers include City Stone, Holland Stone, Panorama, Venetian, and more. 

Find the material you’re looking for and grab a quote. One of our experts will reach out to discuss your needs!